• slide-1
  • slide-2
cases seen onBBCCNNGQNew York TimesRolling StonesThe Washington PostAP

Did You Really Do It? RCM 706 – Sanity Board
March 24, 2012

Rule of Court Martial 706 allows military defense attorneys to request a mental examination of their client to determine whether the he or she lacked mental responsibility at the time of the alleged acts. For example, in the upcoming case ofUnited States v. Staff Sergeant Robert Bales, the sanity board request will be extremely important. If the board finds that he lacked mental responsibility for the offenses charged, he may not be tried.

Routinely, trial counsels opposed to the sanity board, and the chain of command follows their advice. It remains for military defense attorneys to collect all the facts to persuade the chain of command, and if necessary, the judge, that a mental examination is critical. Some of the warning signs may be:

  1. PTSD
  2. History of mental problems
  3. Stress, depression, mental or emotional trauma
  4. Addiction(s)
  5. Erratic, unusual behavior
  6. Suicide attempts
  7. Post-deployment stressors

This list is not exclusive. In Staff Sergeant Bales’ case, based on the initial reports, it appears that he suffered from at least a few warning signs mentioned here.

Sanity Boards reveal additional medical issues that many Servicemembers face, in addition to their known medical history. Such findings may be very useful during the actual trial. Also, it is important to note that once the defense places its client’s medical history at issue, the trial counsel will have access to it as well. As such, it is critical to control what the trial counsel will have access to. Finally, sometimes, sanity boards are not done properly, and some questions are not answered by those who examine a particular Servicemember. In such cases, it is critical for military defense attorneys to protect their clients’ rights by using RCM 706 to their advantage.

If you are looking for experienced military defense attorneys who know how to handle requests for sanity boards under RCM 706, how to gather facts, engage the chain of command, and persuasively argue in front of a military judge, contact The Federal Practice Group for a private consultation.

Recent In the News

Rolling Stone: Q&A: 'The Kill Team' Director Dan Krauss on Whistleblowers and War Crimes

In the spring of 2011, Rolling Stone reported the chilling news of a rogue band of soldiers, or "Kill Team," responsible for murdering three Afghan civilians. Although Sgt. Calvin Gibbs...Read Full Article

The Tribeca Film Festival: Making Film the Fourth Estate

Yahoo!: ‘The Kill Team’ Examines Moral Dilemmas Facing Young Soldiers at War

Three years ago, the U.S. was stunned by a horrific story that emerged from the front lines of the war in Afghanistan: Several members of an Army platoon had killed at least three...Read Full Article

Chicago Tribune

Lesbian sailor in a civil union fights fraternization charge

Chief petty officer will face court-martial over relationship with fellow servicewoman of lower rank at Great Lakes base...Read Full Article

Stars and Stripes

Lesbian Sailor in a Civil Union Fights Fraternization Charge

Just as the U.S. military has softened its stance on gays, a chief hospital corpsman at Naval Station Great Lakes...Read Full Article

Information Center